5. “American Horror Story, the weirdest show on TV, turned up the strange Wednesday when the Rubber Man murders a feuding couple, Chad (Zachary Quinto) and Patrick (Teddy Sears), on the eve of Halloween 2010 while in the present Tate (Evan Peters) reveals to Violet (Taissa Farmiga) that the abortionist who built the house (Matt Ross) tried to sew his murdered and rendered infant son back together with pig parts.
4. Burned face Larry (Denis O’Hare), who seemingly dispatched Ben’s (Dylan McDermott) ex-lover, Hayden (Kate Mara), in the previous episode, turns up for his $1,000 and gets aggressive with his collections while Violet is home alone which is when Rubber Man mysteriously appears.
2. Vivien (Connie Britton) experiences a pregnancy complication and the ultrasound image of she and Ben’s unborn kid cause the nurse to faint.
1. Violet’s panicked call sends Ben and Vivien racing home to find a trashed house, Violet missing and a dirt-riddled ghost of Hayden trick-or-treating at the door.